Sunday, March 09, 2008

"The Other Woman" Analysis!

I know I was a little hard on this episode in my Instant Reactions, but I’ve come to realize that there was nothing terribly “wrong” with this episode – it’s just that stacked against to the other mega-awesome episodes this season, there really wasn’t anything terribly “fantastic” about it either – besides the gratuitous scenes of Juliet in a bikini, of course.

Photobucket

Still, even the most mediocre of Lost episodes leaves us with much to ponder, so let’s get it at!

Harper. We were finally introduced to another Other this week, which is long overdue when you consider that aside from Richard Alpert, all the other Others we actually knew by name - Tom, Ethan, and Goodwin - are all dead.

On the other hand, the first question we should ask about Harper is – is she actually still alive? The way that she magically appeared in the jungle following a whisper-fest, and then just as quickly disappeared accompanied by the same whispers brings into question whether she was actually there in person, or was some Walt-like projection (both were wet!), or even could have been a manifestation of Smokey / Jacob designed to trick Juliet into doing the Island’s bidding.

Photobucket

Evidence seems to point to there being at least something a little “special” about her visit, aside from her Houdini-like appearance and disappearance. For one, she mentioned carrying a message from Ben… who has been Locked up (pun) for the past few days in the Barracks, seemingly without a way to communicate with the outside world. Secondly, she knew the intentions of Faraday and Charlotte, which Ben would not have known even if he did have a secret telephone to the Others’ Temple in his basement cell. Unless there are secret cameras and microphones all over the jungle, and Faraday and Charlotte happened to walk by one while discussing their game plan, there’s no way anyone outside of the two of them would know what they were doing. Factor in the somewhat cryptic message of “Ben is exactly where he wants to be”, and I’m leaning towards Harper’s appearance being a product of the Island Spirit.

Assuming that the Island Spirit is some all-knowing being about everyone and everything happening on the Island, it would make sense that it would choose to appear to Juliet (who had a gun, and theoretically the ability to stop Faraday and Charlotte – as opposed to the Others at the Temple, which might be quite far away). It would make sense that it would appear as Harper (a person familiar to Juliet – but more importantly, a person who Juliet somewhat fears, and somewhat owes a favor to for the whole “stealing her husband” deal).

Does this necessarily mean that Harper is dead? No – although most of the “projections” or “Island Spirit” appearances in the past have been dead people (Yemi, Ben’s Mom), we’ve also seen Walt, who was still very much alive at the time. In fact, I think we’re more than likely to see her again in future for the simple reason that we need other Others to care about. We might as well have one with a built-in conflict laden back story with Juliet to help make the future interactions all the more spicy.

As for the character of Harper herself, she appears to be the second confirmed survivor of Ben’s Dharma purge. If you look closely in the background of her office at the start of the episode, you’ll see that there is a certificate with her name presented by the Hanso Foundation. It also seems that having a therapist is a much more Dharma thing to do (crazy cult) than the true Island Originals, who are more crazy hippies. When you think about it, it does make sense that Ben would want to keep Harper around post-purge.

Dharma probably started requiring mandatory visits to a therapist in an effort to help deal with the change in life on the Island – but for Ben, keeping it around post-purge was a way for him to gain information about every member of the Island… information he could later use to his advantage. Based on this, Harper could be just as dangerous a person as Ben (she did seem pretty evil, even in this episode).

Of course, the bad news about this is that it means yet another “Other” we meet isn’t truly an Island original, so Harper will not bring us any closer to understanding things like why the Others don’t age, why they can’t have babies, or how they got to the Island in the first place. Richard Alpert, hurry back to Lost and get an episode of your own!


Widmore. “The Other Woman” also provided the first concrete evidence of Widmore’s connection to the Freightors… and that fresh VHS tapes are at a premium for Others.

While it’s always possible that Ben was totally lying about Widmore being the man behind the Freightors, from a story telling perspective, that wouldn’t make much sense. Last week’s episode seemed to set this week’s up – with Charles Widmore buying the Black Rock Journal, which would eventually lead him to the Island, through the Freightors. Unless the writers are going out of their way to introduce a red herring (which wouldn’t make a ton of sense, given that there are only 42 episodes of Lost left to wrap up all the storylines - and also, out of all the people in the world, why would Ben pick Widmore, someone who meant nothing to John Locke in the first place? Just a big coincidence?), I think that part of Ben’s story is accurate.

Photobucket

I also think Ben’s symbolism as to why Widmore poses such a threat is dead accurate… mostly because it’s the same explanation for the Freightors many of us have had since they arrived – they’re looking to exploit the Island’s unique properties for profit / power. Unfortunately, doing this will pretty much destroy the Others’ current way of life and intimate relationship with the Island, so it’s a threat worthy of doing everything in their power to prevent… even if that means killing innocent people (like Naomi).

The one part of his story that didn’t make sense was that Widmore captured an Other Spy, beat him up, and killed him. For me, Charles Widmore always struck me as more Gates than Godfather – someone who may be ruthless to competitors and a shrewd businessman, but not someone who would dirty their hands with something as violent as murder. It’s hard to argue with the tape, since it’s clear Widmore was at least a part of dealing with someone blindfolded and kidnapped, but this would mean that Ben was telling Locke the total truth, which can’t actually happen, can it?

Photobucket

I’m curious to see how much more of Widmore we see this season. My gut feeling is that we may get some more confirmation of his involvement with the Freightors this season, but that he will come to the forefront as the action shifts more to the post-Island life of the Oceanic Six. Even if he isn’t The Economist (although it would be much cleaner if he was), his presence would provide a great counter to Ben’s – giving our Survivors (and the audience) two opposing points of view of “right” or “wrong” concerning returning to the Island and picking sides in the battle for control of it – and keeping the Lost tradition of blurring the line between good and evil.


Tempest. Speaking of evil, it seems that the Tempest was designed to serve one purpose… to kill every person on the Island who wasn’t wearing a gas mask. The creepy thing is that this was clearly designed by the Dharma Initiative (since Ben used it against them – irony!). Why would Dharma equip the Island with such a thing? Since it was originally developed by Dharma, it was likely some form of defense – a last ditch effort they could employ in case of an attack by Others. Some warning would sound, every member of the Dharma Initiative would pull a gas mask out from under their bed / desk / chair, and calmly watch as all the Others dropped like flies around them.

However, since Ben continued to keep the Tempest functional post-purge, the purpose seems to have shifted towards protection from outsiders – something that Ben and the Others could use in case of an attack. But if this were the case, why didn’t Ben just use it right after the crash of Oceanic Flight 815? Wouldn’t that have saved the Others a lot of time and effort, ensured that no Others died at the hands of our Survivors, and ultimately kept the Island secret from the outside world? Furthermore, if Ben really did have the ability to set off the Tempest at any time, why fear the Freightors? Let them all come to the Island, unleash the fury, and continue to fill up the hole of dead purge bodies in the middle of the jungle – nothing to worry about. Lastly, we learned that Ben was keeping the Tempest secret from the other Others – note Goodwin lying about working in a “power station”. So how in the world did the Freightors know that it existed at all, let alone where on the Island it was located?

Photobucket

Therein lies my problem with the Tempest. While it does serve some purpose (explaining how the Dharma Purge was carried out), it doesn’t make sense in fitting with the rest of the ongoing storylines. The fact that it wasn’t included on the Blast Door Map, or mentioned in any earlier episodes, really makes it feel like nothing more than a plot device introduced for this single episode… and resolved this episode, meaning we’ll never hear about it again.


The List. On the other hand, it was nice to see “the list” get some long overdue attention again this episode. If you recall, these lists seem to have been created by Jacob – indicating which Survivors were “worthy” of becoming Others, and which were not. Apparently Zack and Emma were on the list (which makes sense given the Others’ penchant for freaky experiments on kids), but most of our Survivors – who admittedly have pretty sketchy pasts – were not.

The weird thing is how Juliet seems to have bought into the logic behind these lists during her conversation with Ben this episode. From everything we’ve seen, it seems pretty obvious that Ben is the true mastermind behind who was and wasn’t on these lists (although I’m sure he would claim that Jacob told him who to write down) – but if the all-powerful Jacob was really creating them, why would he need Goodwin and Ethan to gather intel on our Survivors before creating them? No, it seems as though the lists were simply a way for Ben to justify who he wanted to invite to his exclusive club, and who he didn’t.

Juliet’s lack of questioning about these lists makes it appear that she buys in to the whole concept of Jacob – something I find hard to believe given her character’s logical and questioning nature. Remember, when the plane crashed, she was the one having a book club with “outlawed books”, questioning if free will still existed on the Island. Suddenly, a month later she is calmly discussing the kidnapped children from Oceanic Flight 815 because they appeared on some list?

It doesn’t add up for me. Unless we missed a crucial scene in her flashbacks that shows her being brainwashed in Krazy Karl’s Rave Room, this scene felt out of place for her character. But it’s still nice to know the writers haven’t forgotten about Zack and Emma. Here’s hoping we get some resolution to what happened to them before the series runs out.


Ben. Based on the Island timeline, it took Ben exactly four days to go from being an inch away from being beaten to death as a captive of our Survivors, to living freely in the Barracks, acting as co-leader of Team Island. This guy is good. No wonder Harper (or Projected Image of Harper) told Juliet he was exactly where he wanted to be.

It’s a little bit strange that Ben chose to use the same phrase as Miles did when both were in captivity. For Miles, that place seemed to simply be where he could strike an outside bargain with Ben and profit on lying about him being alive… but for Ben, it was being in a place where he could work his way back into power – and maybe back into the good graces of the Island Spirit / Jacob – by helping Team Island defeat the Freightors.

I’m still not sure why the Island Spirit has stopped communicating with Locke (he hasn’t done anything wrong as far as I can tell since he seemed to become BFF with the Island during last season’s finale), but it’s looking like we’re going to have to rely on Ben to get the Team Island storyline jumpstarted beyond everyone hanging out at the Barracks. Please go visit the Temple and reunite with the Others!

Photobucket

“The Other Woman” also provided the background to some of the tension we’ve seen between Juliet and Ben in the past. Apparently Ben was smitten with Juliet because she looked just like “her" (most likely former flame Annie, but a lot of the Oedipus fans out there are saying Ben’s mom), but Juliet had eyes for Goodwin… which actually lead to him being killed (another terribly illogical plot point, by the way – how would Ben know that Ana-Lucia would accidentally kill Goodwin? Does this mean that Ethan also wronged Ben in some way and he knew that Ethan would die?)

In the end, supposedly this means that Jack is in big trouble after Ben takes care of the Freightors, since he’s currently smooching Juliet – but we all know that Jack makes it off the Island alive, so it must not be an immediate threat.

Photobucket


Boatman. Lastly, we come to everyone’s favorite topic of debate from the past episode – who is Ben’s man on the boat? Based on Ben asking Locke to sit down before hearing the identity, it means Ben’s Man must be someone that Locke knows (Michael, Walt) or someone who is supposedly dead that Locke knows (Anthony Cooper, Tom), or someone totally puzzling outrageous (Ben himself, Jacob).

While you could argue for either of the later two points, the first seems to be by far the most likely. A lot of people have been hoping for Walt to end up being Ben’s inside man just to offer some surprise to otherwise blatant signs pointing towards Michael… but I’m still not buying it. For me, the most logical (and actually genius) way to handle the dangling storylines of Michael and Walt is as follows:

Show Walt in flashforwards this season, where the actor’s aging works in favor of the storytelling, making him look precisely as old as he should – then involve him in the forthcoming “return to the Island” storyline in later seasons where we can get some answers about his “powers” and connection to the Island.

Have Michael be Ben’s Boatman, giving him the opportunity for redemption (by saving our Survivors from the Freightors) for his past crimes, and a way to easily arrive back on the Island. How do we get to this point?

Show a flashback where Patchy learns of the Freightors’ approach to the Island. Have Ben work out a deal with Michael where he sends him off the Island (and guarantees Walt’s safe return home) and offers him a chance to redeem himself by saving his friends by gathering information about the Freightors and funneling it to him. Send Michael on bearings to intersect with the Freighter.

Pretty easy right? Well, not quite.

There’s still this pesky issue – what happened to Walt? If Michael is on the boat, wouldn’t Walt also be on the boat? If the Freightors arranged to send Walt back to the real world, why would they allow Michael to stick around on the boat, rather than also sending him back to the real world?

One word – information.

Michael offers the Freightors information about the Island and the Others – everything he’s learned during his time there, and offers to help them reach the Island. This could open up a pretty interesting Alias-esque double cross where we aren’t sure if Michael is actually working for Ben, or actually working with the Freightors to take down Ben – but either way, his end mission could be to help our Survivors get off the Island, which he views as a way to partially redeem himself for killing Ana-Lucia and Libby.

It’s pretty neat and logical, but still offers some potential exciting twists and turns, which I like. The only part I don’t like is how obvious the writers have made Michael’s return to the viewers. Of course, there’s always the chance that I’m way off and Ben’s Boatman will turn out to be Vincent… which would also be awesome.

Okay – that’s all for this week. Get commenting!

http://facethewoods.com/lost/index.php?topic=277.0

30 comments:

Rebecca said...

One point you didn't mention... considering how broken up Juliet was over Goodwin, it wasn't that long before she's smooching Jack?!! What, Goodwin's been dead for what, two months island time?

The girl moves on fast I guess.

RutkowskiLives said...

One thing that I caught watching this a second time was during Charlotte and Juliet's conversation about Ben. Charlotte asks Juliet if she's convinced that Ben wouldn't gas everyone on the island, and then Charlotte says "We know he's done it before."

Wait, what?

How would they know that?

Anonymous said...

Brian, I don't think the Tempest was designed as a gas repository rather it seems to be a wave generated power station (no sign of the giant hamsters in a wheel ben mentioned to locke).

The location near the beach and a wave as its logo seems to indicate that to me but i could be wrong....

Anyone else think the same?

Cheers, Dennis.

Hope said...

I think there are reasonable explanations for how Harper could have known where Charlotte and Faraday were going. I think Ben's man on the boat could have informed Ben what they had planned. They obviously knew this was their mission once they got on the island. Then Ben could have let the Others/Harper know of their intentions either before he was captured or maybe after he was captured if there is a camera in Ben's cell that the Others are monitoring.

Gekco said...

Ben's man on the boat could still be someone from Locke's past that was significant.

Maybe that cop he was pointing the rifle at, that we don't know if he shot (assuming he didn't have it in him then). Or one of the people from the commune after they get out.

That would be a shock to me, and wouldn't water down the show with a sudden or out of pace flashback.

(about the next episode)
They said we would meet the last of the Oceanic 6. But my, and my fathers count, is only 4 have been named: Jake, Kate, Sayid, Hurley.

So does that mean they are counting Arron as one of them? Or did we just blank out a whole section of the show.

--Gekco

smacky said...

While Goodwin was definitely sent away to get him away from Juliet, Ethan was sent to just get information. HOWEVER, Ethan went off-task and kidnapped Claire, which Tom told him he wasn't supposed to do, and which Juliet repeated to Jack ("Ethan was acting on his own"). In light of Ethan acting as a "loose cannon," Ben probably didn't cry over Ethan's death. You can't have people under you who don't follow orders. That was Ethan's "crime."

Anonymous said...

I think the "her" that Harper told Juliet she looks just like is Ben's mom (or whoever is pictured holding the hamster in the painting in his house). I don't think Ben would have told anyone, especially Harper, about his childhood love.

And I'm intrigued by discussions that Ben could be sabotaging pregnancies on the island because his own mother died in childbirth.

-- lost and back again

CJ said...

Maybe the last of the Oceanic Six includes Sun AND Jin.

Jennifer said...

Gekco -- Aaron is one of the Oceanic 6. He's obviously among the people that end up getting rescued and taken back to civilization (with Kate claiming him as her son), so that makes him count as one of the survivors.

Good analysis, Brian!

Anonymous said...

Glad to see Brian addressed the matter of Julliete buying-into the "list". To me, this remains a disturbing gap in this characters story-line that begs for further explanation to make it plausible/credible. For her to simply accept some "list" as gospel is entirely implausible.

As for Ben's man on the boat, the idea it could be Anthony Cooper is interesting however not gonna happen. Why? The ex-producers have made it very clear and vowed, in pod-casts, that when a character is clearly killed off (unlike Patchy originally), he is dead. NO DOUBT THAT THE 'MAN ON THE BOAT' IS MICHAEL. Somehow, Walt's lack of appearance will be explained.

Finally, "her" I suggest, is more likely to be revealed as Anne than Ben's mother. I bet we'll hear about Anne in a Ben flashback - no way he allowed her to die in the purge!

Anonymous said...

One other question.....what were the frieghtor people trying to do in the Tempest? Were they trying to gas everyone? Or, were they doing, as Charlotte said? What was Harper (Ben) trying to accomplish by interferring with their effort there?

Anonymous said...

What about the option of Tom and Richard (or other Others) being on a boat just outta view and "take the kid from the raft" again. They tell Michael what he needs to do, and then he and Walt will be reunited and allowed to go home?

Possible?

Anonymous said...

2 points:

1. Nobody addressed why the Tempest was going off in the first place... which is why Farraday was there turning it off. Did Ben set it off? Island? Remotely?

2. You know why the Island & Locke don't get along anymore since the season finale? Locke killed Naomi with the knife in the back that episode... rather out of Locke's character, no?

wgh said...

Ben sent Goodwin into potential danger because he hated his guts... maybe hoping he would get killed.... but certainly couldn't have foreseen it the way it happened. I took that scene to demonstrate what a slick opportunist Ben is... making hay of the discovery of Goodwin's dead body by implying he was responsible.

Anonymous said...

question..what if the man on the boat is the russian that worked for Ben. He is very skilled at international communications and intelligence gathering, has survived death once, and we never actually saw him die when he killed charlie. He has a connection to Lock as that da*n russian that just won't die. Further we don't know that he wasn't in contact with the freighter before leaving the island. If he infiltrated them as an informant no one would ever know. Last we saw, he was at communications station in ocean.

heat said...

I'm new to the blog this season and I love it. It makes watching Lost even more fun!

I'm not so sure Aaron would be considered one of "the 6". Technically, he was not a passenger of 815. He didn't have a ticket, and he's not listed on the manifest.

VictorC said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
VictorC said...

Good analysis as always Brian.

I don't know if you forgot, but there are several question marks in the blastdoor map, one of these could be The Tempest. I just really doubt that the Lost writers would introduce such an important hatch on a whim, I'm sure it had to be planned (judging by their track record so far in the show).

Smacky, good catch on Ethan.

Anonymous, Faraday was the one who set off The Tempest, he started shutting things down in order to initiate the sequence. I think they're preparing the way for the freighters to invade the island.

Heat, Aaron should be one of the O6, he was in the womb, inside the plane, therefore a survivor of the crash.

Few questions:
Brian do you have any theories on Charlotte knowing what Ben did to the rest of the Dharma people?

Why did Juliet and Jack's torches not go out during the rain??

Anonymous said...

How plausible is the overall timeline on Island when one considers Juliette finding out Ben wanted Goodwyn killed and her being friendly towards him?

heat said...

Victorc...I see your point about Aaron.

I have a question. If the Island (spirit) was the one who wanted to stop Charlotte and Faraday, why use an image of Harper to tell Juliet to do it? Why not send smokey?
And I agree with a comment someone made several episodes ago about why nobody is afraid to walk around in the jungle anymore. What happened to the bears and wild boars and all?

JustMe said...

I think the 'her' is Annie... and that Annie was the first to conceive post-purge (with Ben's baby) and the first of many mamas-to-be who died during childbirth.

Ben threw off some sort of island balance with his purge and hence feels compelled to fix his mistake and do right by Annie.

Just a thought...

lauren said...

"and that fresh VHS tapes are at a premium for Others."


classic!!!

you forgot to mention harper saying to juliet during therapy "of course he is, you look just like her."

JUST LIKE WHO!

Pete said...

You made some comment how the others dont have many VHS tapes... I think the "Red SOX" being on the tape was a plot device to show that the Widmore tape happened AFTER the Red Sox won the World Series... Hence after the plane crashed and before the submarine blew up.

-Pete
Favorite quote of the show: "I'm not lookin' for Jack.... I'm lookin' for the submarine!"

Anonymous said...

Pete....very good point. Why else would the writters have had Ben use an old Red Sox tape? A plot device is a likely answer.

Pecma said...

I'm sticking with my Walt is the man on the boat theory.

I'm am going to avoid your "pre-hash" for this weeks episode. I figure if I see the cast list like you put up it might give up who is the man on the boat and I want to be surprised.

The big question is, during which part of the show will we find out? Last 2 minutes? probably.

Anonymous said...

Official D&C Podcast

1) Scripts 9 and 10 are done and 11 is almost done.
2) Two Hour Finale will now air in two episodes over two weeks because of Grey's Anatomy having a two-hour finale
3) Iron Man Trailer was cool

4) The Other Woman - What is the use of the Tempest? Are the hatches important?
D&C: They joke about the Arrow hatch, but confirm that they all have some importance and that the Tempest is a very important hatch on the island. This episode was their way of telling us about some of the island's history via Juliet's past on the island. To show us how the Dharma Initative was potentially gassed. Dharma was working on Biological weapons, but are not necessarily bad.

5) Is Widmore really the man behind the freighter?
D&C: Yes and this is a BIG reveal on the show. Ben knows why Widmore is trying to get to the island and we should know by the end of the season alos. They confirm Ben is lying.

6) Will we see Harper again?
D&C: Yes we will, she is an other, we did not kill her and she is still on the island.

7) Who is Ben's Man on the Boat?
D&C: We will find out this week in Ji Yeon (Episode 4x07)

8) Canon of LOST? Mobisodes, Find815, TLE, Via Domus and Orchid!?
D&C: Good question, the show is the Mothership and is indeed the main canon. Also it is tricky to keep our eyes on everything else in the LOST Universe. We give a framework to the creators but what we write is truly canon. The Mobisodes are, so is the Orchid video which will come into play later this season. Certain elements in other items such as Hanso perhaps in Bad Twin are canon and there are other little tidbits in everything else to make it fun for fans, but at the end of the day main thing to follow is the show.

9)Lost and Gilligan Island
D&C: Answer several joke type questions. Lol, Skipper borrowed Minnow from Libby and is a member of Dharma. :)

11) CS appears in Season 1, CS appears in Mobisode 13, CS appears in Episode 4x01 in Jacob's cabin, will we see more of CS in the future of LOST.
D&C: Yes, we will see him several more times and a good question to ponder of CS is how he is a part of the lives of Jack and the other Losties.

12) Will we see Smokey?
D&C: Yes we will smokey this season. They try to show us smokey at least once a season, but they have "rules".

13) Locke was my favorite character in Season 1, but his actions are getting tougher to defend. Will his actions be redeemed?
D&C: Locke is on a journey and in journeys there are periods of doubting and frustrations. It is cool to see a character struggle, but by the end of even this season Locke will have some better moments. A Man of faith might doubt and have struggles, but will emerge as even a bigger believer in faith.

14) Via Domus Ending, was it a dream or Des like time travel?
It wasn't all a dream, some moments in the game were little dreams, but the end is NOT a dream. The game is outside canon so it does not really matter and then they laugh.

15) Podcast host, Chris, really have a job?
Yes, he works at ABC, Disney channel and marketing.

16) Will be back after episode 8 Meet Kevin Johnson with another podcast, who is Kevin Johnson? We will meet him in episode 8. :)

Di said...

Brian—I’m not worried about Juliet’s failure to reject Ben’s lists. I don’t know that she was accepting them so much as she was being tactful in how she approached Ben. By that point she must have learned to tread carefully around him. Also, she wanted something from him, so she would not say, “Ben, we got everyone on your stupid list, now can my lover Goodwin come home?” She also mentioned Zach and Emma to Ben, to see if there was something she could do for them, and she got a response indicating that he had no empathy at all for their plight. So she backed off. Ben showing her Goodwin’s dead body and announcing “You’re mine,” was probably what pushed her over the edge into trying to get Jack to kill Ben.

I was also surprised that Widmore got his hands dirty. It’s possible that the captive was a crucial source and they got enough information from him to send out the freighter (timing might fit), and so maybe Widmore got personally involved. It also seemed odd that Ben has enough of a network to be able to capture this on surveillance but could not (it seems) intervene to save his man. And why would such footage end up taped over the Red Socks? Was Mikhail doing long distance surveillance from the Flame?

RE: Harper’s comment to Juliet: “You look just like her.” My first thought was that “her” is Annie--it would fit. But I looked back at pictures, and Annie had straight brown hair, whereas Ben’s mother had hair similar to Juliet’s—curly and blonde. Sure, there are other important issues in similarity, but the hair stands out for me. And it seems that Ben keeps that painting of his mother on his wall. So now I’m thinking that “her” is Ben’s mother.

Rutkowskiilives—great catch, about Charlotte saying that they know Ben has used gas before. How WOULD she know? We’ve speculated that maybe Dharma doesn’t know that something had gone wrong on the Island, but maybe they do—in which case, why haven’t they come to take their Island back? How would someone else know? Maybe there were survivors, or maybe Ben sent Annie off the Island before gassing everyone, and she knew what he was planning and told. I’m wondering again—what was “The Incident” that led to the initiation of the button-pushing protocol? Maybe there was a previous attempt by outsiders to take the Island, and so Dharma launched some defensive programs, including the gas manufacturing.

Craig said...

I got the feeling that Widmore's look towards the camera at the end of that sequence could also be more of a "Did you get that?" sort of look, rather than a "is that someone watching us?".

So, whoever took it was in on it and its an act.

Just raising it as a possibility - I also dont like it as a story line, BUT I also dont think Widmore 'looks' bad enough to be Ben's arch enemy!! He's bad, but not 'that' bad- you know?

singhy said...

One thing which jumped out at me is when Juliet said to Ben "now we've got everyone on the list [from the tail section]...let Goodwin come back". Now, they didn't snatch Cindy until just before the tail section survivors were reunited with the main losties - well after Goodwin was killed.

So does that mean Cindy wasn't on the list, and if so, why did we see her as a seemingly accepted member of The Others on the Hydra island last season? Or is it a writer mistake (God forbid!)?

Anonymous said...

I know I'm late to the party, but I thought I should note something: Babies that can sit on a parent's lap do not have to have their own ticket, and thus would not appear on the passenger manifest. However, it would be well-known that Kate didn't have a kid. The question, then, is whether Aaron is truly adopted, or if Kate is pretending to be his biological mother.